Sandman Mystery Theatre #2
☆ Be the first to review + Add to your collection — Join freeThis second volume of Sandman Mystery Theatre collects issues #5-8 of the 1990s series, featuring two complete story arcs: 'The Face' and 'The Brute.' In these noir-tinged tales set in 1930s New York, Wesley Dodds—the gas-masked vigilante known as the Sandman—investigates a serial killer targeting plastic surgery patients and a brutal strongman terrorizing the city. Written by Matt Wagner with art by Guy Davis and John Watkiss, the book deepens the character's pulp-inspired detective work and personal struggles.
In "The Face, Act One," Jimmy Shan finds himself caught between loyalty to his Lei Feng tong and the chilling reality of a killer targeting rival members—each victim beheaded with eerie precision. As the Sandman, ever watchful, urges Jimmy to stop the escalating violence, the true horror unfolds in silence: a man in a mask returns to his apartment, peeling away his disguise to whisper to his own reflection. Written by Matt Wagner and illustrated with stark precision by John Watkiss, with colors by David Hornung and letters by John Costanza, this issue builds tension through quiet dread. The cover, by Gavin Wilson, captures the unsettling stillness of a face revealed.
In the shadowed alleys of Chinatown, a brutal tong war erupts as beheaded bodies turn the streets into a crime scene of terror. The Sandman, drawn into the chaos, must unravel a twisted conspiracy where violence is a weapon and the truth is buried beneath layers of deception.
In "The Face, Act Two," Jimmy Shan finds himself caught between loyalty to his Lei Feng tong and the chilling reality that the recent beheadings aren’t the work of their sworn enemies, the Huo Yibai tong. As the Sandman presses him to stop the escalating violence, Jimmy’s pleas fall on deaf ears—until a new murder forces the truth to the surface. The Face, after another kill, retreats to his apartment, peeling away his mask to speak in whispers to his own reflection.
In "The Face, Act Three," Jimmy Shan is caught between loyalty to his tong and a growing danger as his boss, Hsu Chang, refuses to end the violent conflict. As Dian draws closer to Jimmy, the stakes rise—especially when Jimmy becomes a target of The Face’s unseen master. Meanwhile, the Sandman closes in on the killer’s hidden lair, bringing the mystery to a tense, pivotal moment.
In "The Brute, Act One" from Sandman Mystery Theatre #2, Wesley Dodds finds himself drawn into a murky partnership with the enigmatic and increasingly suspect fight promoter Arthur Reisling—unaware that Reisling’s shadow holds a far more dangerous secret. As Dodds navigates the web of deception, the line between patron and predator begins to blur.
In "The Brute, Act Two," the Sandman digs deeper into Reisling’s criminal empire, uncovering a massive heroin deal with the Gamboni family and a network of new, untested markets. With the Brute still serving as Reisling’s brutal enforcer, the detective’s investigation takes a darker turn—each step closer to the truth bringing him face to face with the cost of justice in a city that’s already lost too much.
In "The Brute, Final Act," Jo confronts the brutal legacy of a father's cruelty as Ramsey seeks vengeance for his daughter’s suffering. The Sandman uncovers the shocking truth behind the Brute’s identity—Maria Reisling, a forgotten child shaped by neglect and silence—while a deadly drug deal between Reisling and Gamboni erupts into chaos, leaving only blood and unanswered questions in its wake.
ComicBooks.com Value
This exact issue on ebay
Raw — VF/NM ▾ $3.96–$4 2 listings
Raw / ungraded ▾ $2.49–$28.28 6 listings
More listings for this title
Where to buy
Read it digitally
Sell my copy
Have this issue — or a whole collection? Get a fair offer from us, skip the marketplace fees and the hassle.
We Buy Collections ▸Full credits
Reprints
↩ Reprints Sandman Mystery Theatre #5 (1993), Sandman Mystery Theatre #6 (1993), Sandman Mystery Theatre #7 (1993), Sandman Mystery Theatre #8 (1993), Sandman Mystery Theatre #9 (1993), Sandman Mystery Theatre #10 (1994), Sandman Mystery Theatre #11 (1994), Sandman Mystery Theatre #12 (1994)
Reviews
Reader reviews
No reader reviews yet.