ComicBooks.com Register / Loginit's free!
HomeSecret Love › #5
Secret Love #5 cover
📖 Read freeFull issue · restored, free to read

Secret Love #5

Feb 1958 · Farrell · 0.10 USD
☆ Be the first to review + Add to your collection — Join free

This anthology issue contains multiple love stories and an advice column. The primary narrative follows a woman named June who suffers a terrible accident falling down stairs while wearing a wedding gown intended for her "phantom rival," and she dies from her injuries, with her lover Sam left devastated by guilt and loss. The issue also features "Goodbye Yesterday," an untold story visible on the cover, and includes "Edith Wood Lovelorn Editor," an advice column addressing readers' romantic problems, including letters about sibling rivalry over a shared boyfriend and an age-gap relationship concern.

Contains 5 stories
We Make Our Own Future!
7 pp · Romance
Sam AmesJune PetersMary AmesMrs. AmesRoger Peters

June Peters returns to her hometown after years away, reuniting with Sam Ames, her former sweetheart, now a man engaged to Mary Ames. As she tries to rekindle their romance, she finds herself entangled in a delicate web of old feelings, social expectations, and the quiet resistance of a man determined to protect his present.

Goodbye Yesterday
4 pp · Romance
RuthPaul Harris

Ruth arrives in the Colorado hills to escape her grief over her late husband, Phil, only to be met by the brooding guide Paul Harris. As they spend time together, Ruth begins to notice the emotional walls Paul has built, and a growing connection sparks between them—though Paul’s sudden coldness and cryptic past leave her wondering what secret he’s hiding.

Never Doubt Me!
2 pp · Romance
Michael TurnerTerry CrainSanford Lyman

Sanford Lyman, left behind at Michael Turner’s hunting lodge, discovers a shocking truth through a revealing shadow cast by a fire—evidence that challenges his feelings about Terry Crain and Michael Turner’s relationship. As tension mounts, Terry’s sudden realization hints at a moment of emotional reckoning, but the full consequences remain uncertain.

My Phantom Rival
5 pp · Romance
Bill JamesonPeggyJimmy

Peggy grows increasingly troubled as Bill Jameson begins to pull away from their engagement, missing dates and seeming distracted—leaving her to wonder if he still loves her. When she confronts him at his home, she’s shocked to discover he’s been secretly crafting an elaborate bridal chest, a surprise meant to express his devotion in his own quiet way. The story captures her emotional journey from suspicion to revelation, all while keeping the true source of Bill’s absence a tender, unexpected secret.

The Broken Promise!
6 pp · Romance
Ronnie IvesMikePaul Starr

Ronnie Ives arrives in New York to pursue her singing dreams, determined to honor her promise to Mike, the boy back home, by staying loyal to him. As she trains under her young, kind-hearted vocal coach Paul Starr, their bond deepens, blurring the lines between mentor and friend—until Mike unexpectedly shows up, shattering the quiet certainty of her resolve.

ComicBooks.com Value

Our Model is In Beta
Raw (VG) $7
Our model’s value — refined as new sales data arrives · CGC census counts shown where available

Find on

Search eBay for Secret Love #5
No confirmed live listings for this exact issue right now — this opens an eBay search.

Read it digitally

Amazon Kindle Buy the digital edition GlobalComix Indie & digital reader
Opens a search on each platform — digital availability varies by title.

Sell my copy

Have this issue — or a whole collection? Get a fair offer from us, skip the marketplace fees and the hassle.

We Buy Collections ▸
Fast, fair offers · we handle grading & shipping

Reprints

Reprinted in True Romance #3 (1959)

Reviews

Reader reviews

No reader reviews yet.