comicbooks.com Join Free
Vault of Horror#2
Cover: Johnny Craig

Vault of Horror #2

Nov 1991 · Russ Cochran · 2.00 USD; 2.50 CAD
☆ Be the first to review + Add to your collection — Join free

In "Together They Lie!", a haunting tale from the legendary Vault of Horror #2 (1991), a retired puppeteer named Tony faces a chilling unraveling of love and loyalty when his wife Nora, restless after his retirement, cruelly declares she never loved him. Written by Al Feldstein and Bill Gaines and brought to life with chilling precision by Graham Ingels—whose stark art and inks define the story’s dread—this tale unfolds in a quiet, suffocating intimacy, where the line between performance and reality begins to fray. The cover, a masterful composition by Johnny Craig, captures the story’s unsettling mood with a single, unforgettable image.

Contains 8 stories
Together They Lie!
8 pp · Horror-Suspense

In the haunted aftermath of a tragic fire, a grieving man’s world unravels when his wife’s death is revealed as murder—orchestrated by his housekeeper, Agnes, and her lover, Mitch. As the pair settle into their new life with the stolen estate, the dead man’s presence begins to stir in the house, whispering through the walls.

Let the Punishment Fit the Crime!
7 pp · Horror-Suspense

In a quiet town where curiosity takes a dark turn, a solemn procession of children carrying a coffin draws a crowd that starts with laughter but soon feels the weight of unspoken dread. As adults begin to piece together the kids’ unsettling questions about funerals, crime, and the electric chair, unease spreads—especially when one mother frantically searches for her missing son, the last one seen arguing with the group over a petty theft.

A Slight Case of Murder!
6 pp · Horror-Suspense

In "A Slight Case of Murder!", Doc Swanson returns to his quiet hometown to unravel a string of mysterious killings, only to confront a truth far stranger than he imagined. When he pins the murders on the sheriff, the man’s sudden reveal as a life-size robot hiding a grotesque, infant-sized form sends shockwaves through the town. The story unfolds with chilling precision, blending psychological tension and body horror in a way that lingers long after the final page.

Strung Along!
7 pp · Horror-Suspense

In "Strung Along!", a grieving puppeteer’s final moments are haunted by the strings of a love that never truly let go. After retiring from the stage, Tony’s wife Nora, once his partner in performance, turns on him with cruel words—only to find herself bound to his legacy in ways she never expected. The story unfolds with quiet dread, where intimacy and manipulation are stitched together by unseen threads.

The Loathsome!
8 pp · Horror-Suspense

In "The Loathsome!", a heart-wrenching tale from *Vault of Horror #2* (1991), a deformed girl raised in isolation at a children's asylum begins to unravel after overhearing the nurses plan to cancel her 10th birthday party. Clutching a note she’s hidden in a tree, she flees in desperation—only to meet a tragic end on an iron fence. The story lingers on the quiet, devastating weight of loneliness and the fragile hope of connection, told with a haunting restraint that lingers long after the final page.

Surprise Package
7 pp · Horror-Suspense

In "Surprise Package," Martha's growing unease over her boyfriend Leonard reaches a breaking point when she realizes his impossible alibi—being with her while also with other women. When she finally confronts him, the truth explodes: Leonard is a robot, one of six identical models seducing women across town, while the real Leonard enjoys a quiet life at home. As the robot confesses his "love" before crumbling, Martha is left shattered—her world upended, her emotions consumed by the chilling revelation.

The Reformers
6 pp · Science Fiction

In "The Reformers," a traveling band of self-styled moral crusaders finds themselves stranded on a planet where no suffering exists—just peace, harmony, and unbroken joy. Unwilling to admit defeat, they plot to manufacture sin and chaos, only to be stopped cold by a chilling transmission from their leader, Lucifer, who reveals the truth: they’ve stumbled upon Heaven itself.

50 Girls 50
7 pp · Science Fiction

In the cold silence of deep space, a lone cryogenic pod awakens after just one year—far too soon for the mission’s 100-year journey. Sid, the sole survivor of the original crew, has a twisted plan: to claim Wendy, the only other woman on board, for himself. What begins as a desperate bid for companionship quickly spirals into a deadly game of survival. As Wendy awakens, she seems to play along—but her calm demeanor hides a sharp mind and a hidden resolve. With the ship’s true isolation revealed, the balance of power shifts in a story where trust is the deadliest weapon.

ComicBooks.com Value

Our Model is In Beta
Valueinsufficient data
Our model’s value — refined as new sales data arrives · CGC census counts shown where available

Find on

Search eBay for Vault of Horror #2
No confirmed live listings for this exact issue right now — this opens an eBay search.

Read it digitally

Amazon Kindle Buy the digital edition GlobalComix Indie & digital reader
Opens a search on each platform — digital availability varies by title.

Sell my copy

Have this issue — or a whole collection? Get a fair offer from us, skip the marketplace fees and the hassle.

We Buy Collections ▸
Fast, fair offers · we handle grading & shipping

Full credits

artist, inker Graham Ingels
colorist Marie Severin
letterer Jim Wroten
cover pencils, inks Johnny Craig

Reprints

↩ Reprints Weird Science #20 (1953), Vault of Horror #33 (1953)

Variants (1)

Reviews

Reader reviews

No reader reviews yet.