Cynthia

Stepping out of the shadows of DC's beloved horror anthology tradition, Cynthia made her eerie debut in the very first issue of The Witching Hour in 1969 — a Silver Age launch guided by the legendary Alex Toth — and has haunted the pages of DC's spookiest titles ever since. Her presence across The Witching Hour, House of Mystery, and Haunted Tales places her squarely in the atmospheric world of DC's classic horror anthologies, sharing those darkened pages with figures like Mordred, Mildred, Abel, and even Superman himself. The fact that she's kept readers company across nearly five decades and into 2018 speaks to a quiet, enduring power that casual fans may have overlooked. For collectors with a taste for DC's rich horror heritage, Cynthia is exactly the kind of character who rewards a deeper dig into the long boxes.