ComicBooks.com Register / Loginit's free!
Four Color Fear: Forgotten Horror Comics of the 1950s #[nn] cover
Cover: Reed Crandall & Mike Peppe

Four Color Fear: Forgotten Horror Comics of the 1950s #[nn]

Sep 2010 · Fantagraphics · 29.99 USD
☆ Be the first to review + Add to your collection — Join free
About this Collection

This collection gathers a selection of horror and supernatural comic book stories originally published in the 1950s, a decade known for its pre-Code era of gruesome and unsettling tales. Featuring work from lesser-known artists and writers, it highlights the raw, unpolished creativity that flourished before the Comics Code Authority tightened restrictions. The volume offers a glimpse into the forgotten corners of mid-century horror comics, with themes ranging from macabre twists to eerie suspense.

Contains 41 stories
The Strange Case of Henpecked Harry
8 pp · Horror-Suspense

In "The Strange Case of Henpecked Harry," a man driven to desperation by his wife’s relentless torment commits a terrible act in a moment of rage—only to be haunted by visions of her corpse, leading to a terrifying spiral of guilt and paranoia. As Harry’s grip on reality slips, the line between memory and madness blurs, and the truth of what he’s done begins to unravel in ways he never expected.

Pit of the Damned!
7 pp · Horror-Suspense

In "Pit of the Damned!", a desperate carnival owner turns to a forbidden book, summoning demons to lure in crowds with a terrifying new exhibit. As the creatures he’s awakened grow more powerful, he begins to realize too late that some doors should never be opened—and that Hell has its own way of collecting debts.

Corpses... Coast to Coast!
7 pp · Horror-Suspense
A Pact with the Devil
9 pp · Horror-Suspense

In "A Pact with the Devil," Jo finds himself trapped in a desperate bargain that promises golden years of fortune—only to discover the price is far heavier than he ever imagined. As the clock ticks down and shadows close in, he’ll do anything to escape the fate he once welcomed.

The Corpse That Came to Dinner
8 pp · Horror-Suspense

In "The Corpse That Came to Dinner," a newlywed couple's quiet return from their honeymoon takes a chilling turn when they learn their friend took his own life after confessing his unrequited love for the bride. That night, the man’s corpse rises from the grave and makes its way to their apartment, beginning a tense, terrifying confrontation that refuses to end.

The Maze Master
6.67 pp · Horror-Suspense
Swamp Monster
6 pp · Horror-Suspense

In "Swamp Monster," a fugitive fleeing through the dark, tangled swamps stumbles upon a cursed creature that transforms him into a monstrous beast. When he ambushes the sheriff and his deputy from the treetops, his violent fate takes an unexpected turn—caught in a vine, he collapses, his grotesque form dissolving back into the man he once was.

What Was the Discovery
5 pp · Horror-Suspense
Death Sentence
5 pp · Horror-Suspense

In "Death Sentence," reporter Adams pays a visit to a condemned man in prison, only to hear a chilling warning: the world is on the brink of extinction. The inmate claims that a deadly mutant cell, born from a failed experiment by scientists Dean and Radfield, has taken over the world—and Adams, unaware of his own true nature, may be the next link in its spread.

Death Deals a Hand
9 pp · Horror-Suspense

In "Death Deals a Hand," a secretive society gathers under the guise of a high-stakes game, where each meeting ends with one member dead and the survivor claiming the fallen’s fortune. As the body count rises and paranoia takes hold, the final survivor begins to hear whispers—and see shadows—where no one else is.

Custodian of the Dead
7 pp · Horror-Suspense

In "Custodian of the Dead," undertaker Horace Vennery prowls the cemetery under cover of night, stealing from the graves of his own clients—until a cave-in traps him in a coffin, and the rats below claim him. The story unfolds with quiet dread, turning a man of death into prey in a world where the buried may not stay quiet.

Servants of the Tomb!
7 pp · Horror-Suspense
Nightmare
8 pp · Horror-Suspense

In "Nightmare," a struggling writer named Harry stumbles into a mysterious pawn shop where he’s shown a collection of grotesque creatures said to punish those guilty of the seven deadly sins. Drawn into the shop’s eerie atmosphere, Harry finds inspiration in the horrors he sees, fueling a burst of creativity that lands him a breakthrough with his publisher.

Me, Ghost
5 pp · Horror-Suspense
Dust Unto Dust
5 pp · Horror-Suspense
Drum of Doom
5 pp · Horror-Suspense
The Body Maker
7 pp · Horror-Suspense

In "The Body Maker," a twisted artist obsessed with Frankenstein's legacy sets out to craft his ideal bride from stolen body parts, stitching together a monstrous vision of beauty from the corpses of his victims. When his macabre work takes a deadly turn one fateful night, his own creation begins to unravel in ways he never imagined.

Green Horror
5 pp · Horror-Suspense

In "Green Horror," Martha's decision to plant a cactus in her yard sets off a chain of chilling events that defy reason. As her husband George and later her new fiancé Brent meet grisly fates at the hands of the seemingly innocent plant, the line between garden and grave blurs. The story unfolds with quiet dread, turning a simple houseplant into a relentless, unnatural force.

Puppet Peril
7 pp · Horror-Suspense
Untitled Humor story
0.5 pp · Humor
Untitled Humor story
0.5 pp · Humor
Chef's Delight
6 pp · Horror-Suspense

In "Chef's Delight," the cruel and narcissistic chef Francois Nicole rules his kitchen with a tyrant’s hand, lavishing his wealth on a wealthy lover while his wife and children endure squalor and abuse. When a violent beating pushes his wife to the breaking point, her shattered resolve ignites a terrifying act of retribution. The next morning, the other chefs find the kitchen transformed into a grotesque feast—Francois’ organs laid out like a final, horrifying course.

Colorama
5 pp · Horror-Suspense
The Thing from the Sea!
7 pp · Horror-Suspense

In "The Thing from the Sea!", a sailor’s murder at sea sets a chilling course of vengeance, as the drowned Eddie Murray rises from the deep, drawn not by rage but by a haunting devotion to his lost love. As Johnny Smithers tries to win the heart of the man’s girl, the dead man’s slow, relentless journey through the ocean’s dark reaches begins—leading straight to a final, watery reckoning.

The Flapping Head
8 pp · Horror-Suspense
Amnesia!
5 pp · Horror-Suspense

In "Amnesia!", a man struck by lightning while crossing a cemetery wakes with no memory, only to wander into a haunted house where spectral figures stir his fading mind. As shadows close in and forgotten echoes resurface, he stumbles toward a terrifying truth—his name, his past, and the horrifying identity he’s been trying to forget.

Vision of the Gods
1 pp · Fantasy

In "Vision of the Gods," two photographers capturing ancient temples in Ceylon are struck by the sudden appearance of a mesmerizing dancer—beautiful, otherworldly, moving with eerie grace. Back home, everything seems normal, but when they review their film, she’s absent, leaving only silence where her dance once was.

The Man Who Outdistanced Death!
8 pp · Horror-Suspense

In "The Man Who Outdistanced Death!", Chief Whitecloud Comatok, the legendary long-distance runner, faces a terrifying challenge when his rival Georgie Kerrik uncovers the dark secret behind his unmatched endurance—only to find himself running not just to win, but to survive.

I, Vampire
5 pp · Humor, Horror-Suspense
Experiment in Terror
7 pp · Horror-Suspense
Art for Death's Sake!
5 pp · Horror-Suspense
A Safari of Death!
5 pp · Horror-Suspense
Night Screams
9 pp · Horror-Suspense
Here Today...
5 pp · Horror-Suspense

In "Here Today...", a towering stranger named H. Jonathan Aloysius Cruikshank arrives in a quiet town, weaving charm and mystery into every interaction. As his presence unsettles the townsfolk, old grudges begin to surface—though no one suspects the truth behind his imposing stature or the quiet vengeance he’s come to claim.

Cat's Death
8 pp · Horror-Suspense
The Wall of Flesh!
8 pp · Horror-Suspense

In "The Wall of Flesh!", nurse Sheila finds herself trapped in a terrifying ordeal when the sinister Dr. Quantrell pushes her into a grotesque, living wall of pulsating flesh. With time running out and Johnny racing to save her, the line between life and consumption begins to blur.

Nightmare World
4 pp · Horror-Suspense

In "Nightmare World," Herman's experiment with a mysterious chemical pulls him into the depths of the subconscious, where peace quickly gives way to a grotesque encounter. Awakening in the real world, he discovers the nightmare has followed him—his body now twisted into the very monster he once saw.

What's Happeníng at... 8:30 P.M.
5 pp · Horror-Suspense
Valley of Horror
6 pp · Horror-Suspense

In "Valley of Horror," a couple seeking a shortcut stumbles upon Perdition Valley after finding a road map near the scene of a car crash involving a notorious racketeer. What begins as a simple detour quickly takes a sinister turn as they realize the valley is no ordinary place—its quiet streets and eerie stillness hint at a deeper, darker truth.

The Slithering Horror of Skontong Swamp!
11 pp · Horror-Suspense
Doctor Death (host)

In "The Slithering Horror of Skontong Swamp!", a death row escapee named Goldie Ricon flees into the cursed swamplands, only to be bitten by a zombie and tormented by relentless, nightmarish encounters. Haunted and unraveling, he’s drawn back to the very swamp that birthed his terror—back to death row, and to the swamp again.

Evil Intruder
9 pp · Horror-Suspense

In "Evil Intruder," a lonely Trugg seeks connection in a world that fears it, luring a couple into a twisted embrace. After murdering the husband, it binds the wife in a spell that makes her believe the monster is her beloved. When Lucy finally sees the truth in the dark, it's too late — the Truggs claim what they came for.

ComicBooks.com Value

Our Model is In Beta
Valueinsufficient data
Our model’s value — refined as new sales data arrives · CGC census counts shown where available

Find on

Search eBay for Four Color Fear: Forgotten Horror Comics of the 1950s #[nn]
No confirmed live listings for this exact issue right now — this opens an eBay search.

Where to buy

Find on Amazon 🛒 Buy on Amazon
Four Color Fear: Forgotten Horror Comics Of The 1950s

Read it digitally

Amazon Kindle Buy the digital edition GlobalComix Indie & digital reader
Opens a search on each platform — digital availability varies by title.

Sell my copy

Have this issue — or a whole collection? Get a fair offer from us, skip the marketplace fees and the hassle.

We Buy Collections ▸
Fast, fair offers · we handle grading & shipping

Full credits

artist, inker Fred Kida
cover pencils Reed Crandall
cover inks Mike Peppe

Reprints

↩ Reprints Eerie Comics #1 (1947), Adventures into the Unknown #6 (1949), Journey into Fear #2 (1951), Weird Adventures #2 (1951), Eerie #2 (1951), Chamber of Chills Magazine #23 [3] (1951), Weird Adventures #3 (1951), Weird Thrillers #1 (1951), Blue Bolt #111 (1951), Witches Tales #6 (1951), Voodoo Annual #1 (1952), Chamber of Chills Magazine #7 (1952), Chamber of Chills Magazine #8 (1952), Forbidden Worlds #6 (1952), Out of the Night #2 (1952), Nightmare #1 (1952), This Magazine Is Haunted #5 (1952), Unknown World #1 (1952), Mister Mystery #6 (1952), Strange Fantasy #2 [1] (1952), Strange Terrors #2 (1952), Black Cat Comics #39 (1952), Weird Tales of the Future #3 (1952), Black Magic #11 (17) (1952), Ghost Comics #4 (1952), Witches Tales #15 (1952), Beware! Terror Tales #4 (1952), Strange Terrors #4 (1952), Web of Evil #1 (1952), Strange Suspense Stories #4 (1952), Weird Mysteries #2 (1952), Monster #2 (1953), Journey into Fear #12 (1953), Strange Terrors #7 (1953), Chilling Tales #15 (1953), Weird Horrors #7 (1953), Chamber of Chills Magazine #17 (1953), Adventures into Darkness #10 (1953), Weird Mysteries #5 (1953), Worlds of Fear #10 (1953), Out of the Shadows #9 (1953), Web of Evil #5 (1953), Black Cat Comics #45 (1953), This Magazine Is Haunted #12 (1953), Ghostly Weird Stories #120 (1953), Black Cat Comics #46 (1953), Web of Evil #8 (1953), Strange Fantasy #9 (1953), Web of Evil #9 (1953), Adventures into the Unknown #51 (1954), Haunted Thrills #13 (1954), Adventures into the Unknown #53 (1954), Tomb of Terror #14 (1954), Voodoo #14 (1954), Baffling Mysteries #20 (1954), Chamber of Chills Magazine #23 (1954), Strange Fantasy #11 (1954), Black Cat Comics #50 (1954), Mysterious Adventures #20 (1954), Witches Tales #25 (1954)

Variants (2)

Reviews

Reader reviews

No reader reviews yet.